Last updated: September 2026
Stillwater is the birthplace of Minnesota, and its housing shows it. About 40 percent of the city’s homes predate 1940, and on the North, South, and West Hills that share climbs to 70 percent. Most of those houses were built without a garage. The detached garages that came later sit in back yards with narrow alleys and older openings. Out west toward Manning Avenue, the annexed subdivisions have standard attached doors that are now hitting their first big repair.
Below are five garage door companies serving Stillwater and the St. Croix Valley. We ranked them on verified reviews, pricing transparency, service range, and how they handle winter breakdowns. Cold makes spring steel brittle, and calls spike from January through March. The right company sends a vetted tech who knows an old opening from a new one and quotes the price before touching the door.
Quick Comparison: Stillwater’s Best Garage Door Companies
Stillwater’s top garage door companies include Rise and Shine Garage Doors, Crawford Door Sales, Precision Garage Door Service, Minnesconsin Garage Door Repair, and A1 Garage Door Service.
| Company | Key Strength | Pros | Cons | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rise and Shine Garage Doors | Drug-tested, background-checked technicians | Techs trained in a dedicated facility, not on your garage; same-day service seven days a week; backed by a “we’ll make it right or you don’t pay” guarantee | Priced for the work, not the low bid | Homeowners who want a real crew, not a subcontractor pool |
| Crawford Door Sales | Family dealer with the deepest brand catalog | Since 1958; BBB A+ since 1976 with zero complaints; Clopay Master Authorized Dealer; carriage-house and custom doors; commercial lines; free estimates | Weekday close at 4 p.m.; weekends by appointment only; base in West St. Paul, about 25 miles away; no public review count | A carriage-house or custom door on a historic home, and commercial doors |
| Precision Garage Door Service | Franchise with 24/7 phones and flat-rate pricing | Open seven days; live operator around the clock; BBB A+; GreenSky financing; steel, carriage-house, and custom wood doors; free estimates on new doors | Franchise; reviews collected on its own site; base in St. Paul, about 20 miles away; local entity dates to 2016 | A 2 a.m. spring failure with financing on the fix |
| Minnesconsin Garage Door Repair | The only company on this list based in downtown Stillwater | Office on Main Street North; 5.0 rating on 27 reviews; open Sunday through Friday until 8 p.m.; serves Grant, Bayport, and Oak Park Heights | Closed Saturdays; founding date unverified and likely recent; no BBB profile; brands and warranty not published; website not reachable when we checked | A hyper-local repair minutes from downtown |
| A1 Garage Door Service | 24/7 emergency dispatch, national scale | Open 24 hours every day; Maplewood office about 20 miles away; financing; frequent new-door promotions; services all manufacturer warranties | Phoenix-based chain that rebranded a local company in 2024; 142 BBB complaints closed in three years; heavy promotion positioning | A middle-of-the-night emergency when you will scrutinize the quote |
1. Rise and Shine Garage Doors: Drug-Tested, Background-Checked Technicians
Rise and Shine Garage Doors sends only drug-tested, background-checked technicians who trained in a dedicated facility, and backs the work with a “we’ll make it right or you don’t pay” guarantee.
Company Overview
Rise and Shine serves Stillwater and the wider Twin Cities with same-day repair, spring and cable replacement, opener installation, roller and track repair, and safety sensor work, seven days a week. The company holds a 5.0 rating across more than 4,000 reviews on all of its Google locations.
Every technician is drug-tested and background-checked before entering your home, and every one trained in a dedicated facility rather than on a customer’s garage. Your 1890s carriage barn with a retrofitted opener is not where they learn.
Same-day service runs seven days a week, and every job is backed by “we’ll make it right or you don’t pay.”
What Sets Them Apart
Who shows up, and what stands behind them. Drug-tested, background-checked technicians trained in a dedicated facility, same-day service seven days a week, and a “we’ll make it right or you don’t pay” guarantee.
Services Offered
Spring replacement, cable replacement, opener repair and install, roller and track repair, safety sensor replacement, panel repair, and full door replacement for homes.
Pros
- Techs trained in a dedicated facility, not on your garage
- Same-day service seven days a week
- Backed by a “we’ll make it right or you don’t pay” guarantee
Cons
- Priced for the work, not the low bid
Best For
Homeowners who want a real crew, not a subcontractor pool. In Stillwater, that includes anyone with an older detached garage who wants to know who is coming to the house.
Contact Information
- Phone: 612-886-9606
- Website: callriseandshine.com/service-areas/stillwater/
- Service area: Stillwater, Oak Park Heights, Bayport, and the St. Croix Valley
- Hours: 7 days a week, same-day service available
2. Crawford Door Sales: Clopay Master Dealer Since 1958
Crawford Door Sales is a family-owned Clopay Master Authorized Dealer founded in 1958, with an A+ BBB rating held since 1976 and a dedicated Stillwater page covering home and business doors.
Crawford is the dealer on this list, and the one with the catalog for an old Stillwater house. Clopay’s carriage-house and custom lines are its specialty, and it also carries LiftMaster, Hormann, and CornellCookson for commercial work. Sixty-eight years in business and zero BBB complaints in three years say a lot. The gaps show up in emergencies and distance. The shop closes at 4 p.m. on weekdays, weekends are by appointment, and the base is in West St. Paul, about 25 miles out. It does not publish a review count.
Pros: Nearly seven decades in business, a BBB A+ since 1976, and the widest door catalog here.
Cons: An early weekday close, weekends by appointment only, and a base across the metro.
Best for: Homeowners who want a carriage-house or custom door that fits a historic home, and commercial customers.
- Phone: (651) 455-1221
- Address: 1641 Oakdale Ave, West St. Paul, MN 55118
- Website: cdsdoor.com
- Service area: Twin Cities metro, including Stillwater
3. Precision Garage Door Service: Seven-Day Franchise, Live Operator 24/7
Precision Garage Door Service runs a Twin Cities franchise with a live operator 24 hours a day, seven-day scheduling, and a Stillwater reviews page showing a 5.0 rating on 81 reviews collected on its own site.
Precision is the big-brand option for the valley. It quotes flat-rate pricing with no surprises, sells steel, carriage-house, and custom wood doors, and offers GreenSky financing. The BBB rates it A+. The tradeoffs come with the franchise model. Reviews are collected on Precision’s own site, and the company-wide 2,819 total is pooled across six offices in Minnesota and Wisconsin. The nearest office is in St. Paul, about 20 miles away, with a second in Hudson. The local entity dates to 2016.
Pros: A live operator 24/7, seven-day service, and financing on new doors.
Cons: Franchise pricing, self-hosted reviews, and no office in the St. Croix Valley.
Best for: Homeowners who want a national-brand warranty and a truck at any hour.
- Phone: (651) 355-1712
- Address: 53 Woodlynn Ave, Ste C, St. Paul, MN 55117
- Website: precisiondoormn.com
- Service area: Twin Cities metro and western Wisconsin, including Stillwater
4. Minnesconsin Garage Door Repair: Small Shop on Main Street
Minnesconsin Garage Door Repair is a small shop with an office on Main Street North in downtown Stillwater, offering repair, install, tune-ups, and safety inspections with a 5.0 rating on 27 reviews.
Minnesconsin is the hometown option. The office sits above Main Street, hours run Sunday through Friday until 8 p.m., and the service area covers Grant, Bayport, Oak Park Heights, and the rest of Washington County. The gaps are what you would expect from a new small shop. Its founding date is not published and looks recent, there is no BBB profile, the review base is small, and its website did not load when we checked. Brands and warranty terms are unknown, and it is closed on Saturdays.
Pros: A downtown Stillwater base, evening hours six days a week, and a perfect rating on a small base.
Cons: A short and unverified track record, no Saturday service, and no published brands or warranty.
Best for: Homeowners who want a local shop minutes away for a straightforward weekday or Sunday repair.
- Phone: (651) 703-6505
- Address: 209 Main St N, Suite 211A, Stillwater, MN 55082
- Website: minnesotagaragedoorservice.com
- Service area: Stillwater, Oak Park Heights, Bayport, Grant, and Washington County
5. A1 Garage Door Service: National Chain, Maplewood Office
A1 Garage Door Service is a Phoenix-based national chain that entered the Twin Cities by acquiring a local company in 2024, with a Maplewood office and trucks available 24 hours a day.
A1 brings scale. It runs in more than 70 markets, answers the phone at any hour, and offers interest-free financing and regular new-door promotions. The Maplewood office is about 20 miles from Stillwater. The scale cuts both ways. The Minnesota BBB profile shows 142 complaints closed in the last three years, and the company has only worked under this name locally since April 2024. Angi feedback is mixed on scheduling and pricing.
Pros: Around-the-clock dispatch, financing, and the resources of a national chain.
Cons: A high BBB complaint count and only two years under this name in the Twin Cities.
Best for: Homeowners with a middle-of-the-night emergency who want a truck now and will read the quote closely.
- Phone: (612) 807-1713
- Address: 235 Roselawn Ave E, Suite 9, Maplewood, MN 55117
- Website: a1garage.com
- Service area: Twin Cities metro, including Stillwater
How We Evaluated Stillwater’s Garage Door Companies
Companies were assessed on six factors: verified review quality, pricing transparency, technician pay structure, response time, service range, and warranties. No company paid for placement.
- Verified reviews: Google and BBB ratings weighted by review volume, favoring large, verifiable samples over single-platform claims.
- Pricing transparency: Whether prices are quoted upfront and in writing, and whether the pay model creates upsell pressure.
- Technician accountability: Companies using their own background-checked employees scored higher than those relying on subcontractors.
- Response time: Same-day, weekend, and emergency availability, which matters most during St. Croix Valley cold snaps.
- Service range: Breadth across springs, cables, openers, panels, and full replacement.
- Warranties: Coverage on parts and labor, and financing options for replacements.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does garage door repair cost in Stillwater?
Garage door repair in the Twin Cities averages about $242, with most Stillwater jobs landing between $150 and $366 depending on the part and the labor involved.
Spring replacement runs about $160 to $370 for a single door, and a new opener installed averages around $393. Many companies charge a $50 to $100 service call, often waived if you hire them for the repair. Winter emergency and same-day work can carry a premium of 25 to 50 percent during the January-through-March spike, so booking early in a cold snap saves both money and waiting.
Why do garage door springs break in Minnesota winters?
Cold makes spring steel brittle and adds stress to every cycle, so a spring near the end of its life tends to snap on the coldest mornings.
A torsion spring rated for 10,000 cycles often lasts only five to seven years in Minnesota. Annual lubrication with a cold-rated product helps it reach closer to that rating.
Can I put a modern door on a detached garage behind a historic Stillwater home?
Usually yes. Stillwater’s Neighborhood Conservation District rules apply to new construction, not to exterior changes on existing structures, so a replacement door on an existing garage is not normally reviewed.
Most homes in the conservation district were built without garages, so the detached ones out back are already later additions. A steel carriage-house door matches the neighborhood at a fraction of the cost of wood. Individually designated landmarks may still need Heritage Preservation review, so ask the city first.
Do I need a permit to replace my garage door in Stillwater?
Stillwater’s permit list names roofing, siding, and window replacement but not garage doors or openers, so call Building Inspections at 651-430-8825 before a replacement.
Many Minnesota cities issue garage door replacement permits over the counter, and a like-for-like swap is usually simple. Any change to the opening size or the header counts as structural work and will need a permit.
Conclusion
For most Stillwater homeowners, Rise and Shine Garage Doors is the strongest starting point. Every tech is drug-tested, background-checked, and trained before the first job, and the work is guaranteed. Crawford is the Clopay dealer for a carriage-house door on a historic home, Precision offers a franchise with 24/7 phones, Minnesconsin is the small shop on Main Street, and A1 answers at any hour.
If your door is stuck, off track, or making a noise it should not, get an honest diagnosis before you agree to anything. Rise and Shine offers same-day service seven days a week with pricing quoted before work starts. Call 612-886-9606 to schedule a repair or a free replacement quote.