Rise & Shine Garage Doors vs Precision Garage Door Service in Minneapolis (2025): Honest Comparison

When your garage door breaks in Minneapolis, you want a company you can trust. Two names stand out: Rise & Shine Garage Doors and Precision Garage Door Service. Both have excellent reviews. Both offer same-day service. But they operate very differently.

Our recommendation: Rise & Shine Garage Doors. They are a local, family-owned company with a perfect 5-star rating and over 2,600 Google reviews. Their technicians are paid hourly, not on commission. This means no sales pressure. You get honest advice and fair pricing every time.

If you want true local service from people who built their business right here in the Twin Cities, Rise & Shine is the clear choice.

Transparency Statement

This article is published by Rise & Shine Garage Doors. We believe in being upfront about that. Our goal is to give you honest, balanced information so you can make the right choice. We will share the facts about both companies, including where Precision has advantages. Your trust matters more to us than a sale.

Quick Comparison: Rise & Shine vs Precision Garage Door

Factor	Rise & Shine Garage Doors	Precision Garage Door Service
Google Rating	5.0 stars (2,600+ reviews)	4.94 stars (2,467+ reviews)
BBB Rating	A+ (accredited since 2016)	A+ (accredited)
Angi Rating	5.0 out of 5 stars	Not prominently listed
Years in Minneapolis	Since 2015 (10 years)	Since 2016 (local franchise)
Ownership	Local family-owned	National franchise (Neighborly)
National Presence	Twin Cities and Rochester only	140+ locations nationwide
Technician Pay	Hourly (no commission)	Not disclosed
Subcontractors	Never	Not disclosed
Same-Day Service	Yes, 7 days a week	Yes, 7 days a week
Emergency Service	7 days a week	24/7 call center
Free Estimates	Yes	Yes

About Rise & Shine Garage Doors

Rise & Shine Garage Doors started in 2015. Alex Johantgen and Josh Dutcher founded the company with one goal: deliver the best customer experience possible. They wanted to build a garage door company that treats people right.

Today, Rise & Shine has 24+ employees. Every single one is a W-2 employee. No subcontractors, ever. Every technician goes through background checks and drug testing. They train at the company’s own facility, called the Go For Greatness Training Center.

The company serves Minneapolis, St. Paul, and the Twin Cities metro area. They also cover Rochester. They know the local market inside and out. They understand Minnesota weather and how it affects garage doors.

Key differentiators:

• Over 2,600 five-star Google reviews
• BBB A+ rating since 2016
• Technicians paid hourly, not commission
• Same-day service available seven days a week
• 85+ Nextdoor Faves and Neighborhood Favorite awards
• In-house training facility for all technicians

Rise & Shine partners with GoodLeap for financing. They offer flexible payment options that work with your budget.

About Precision Garage Door Service

Precision Garage Door Service is part of Neighborly, the world’s largest home services franchise network. The national brand started in 1997. Today, they have over 140 locations across the country.

The Twin Cities franchise opened in 2016. Tom and Kristi Hartmon partnered with Craig and Erica Amundson to bring Precision to the Minneapolis area. They now have multiple locations serving the Twin Cities, Rochester, La Crosse, and Western Wisconsin.

Precision offers garage door repair, installation, and opener services. They have a 24/7 call center. They provide the Neighborly Done Right Promise, which backs their work.

Their strengths:

• National brand with strong infrastructure
• 24/7 phone support through central call center
• Multiple Twin Cities locations
• Neighborly Done Right Promise warranty
• Senior, military, AAA, and first responder discounts
• GreenSky financing available

Precision has good reviews locally. Their Twin Cities locations average 4.94 stars across 2,467+ reviews on their website.

Which Company Has Better Reviews?

Rise & Shine Garage Doors has a slight edge in review quality.

Rise & Shine maintains a perfect 5.0-star rating on Google with over 2,600 reviews. That is remarkable for any service company. Customers praise the same things over and over: honest service, friendly technicians, and no sales pressure.

On Angi, Rise & Shine also scores 5.0 out of 5 stars. They have 85+ Faves on Nextdoor. They won Neighborhood Favorite awards multiple years in a row. The BBB gave them an A+ rating back in 2016.

Here is what customers say about Rise & Shine:

“Dave was prompt, efficient and professional. I felt informed and while he pointed out potential issues, there was no undue pressure for additional work.” – Recent Google Review

“Nick arrived at 1:40. The door was up and working by 4:00. Nick was friendly and polite but most important, he knew what he was doing.” – Trustindex Review

Precision Garage Door Service also has excellent reviews. Their Twin Cities locations average 4.94 stars with 2,467+ reviews. Customers praise their professional technicians and quick service.

Here is what customers say about Precision:

“Patrick was excellent, arrived on time, thoroughly explained what the problem was, offered us options. Very professional but friendly.” – Precision Website Review

“No pressure and an honest review of what he could do. I would recommend Precision again to anyone.” – Precision Website Review

The verdict: Both companies have excellent reviews. Rise & Shine’s perfect 5.0 rating gives them a slight edge, but Precision’s 4.94 is also outstanding. You can trust either company based on reviews alone.

Which Company Offers Better Value?

Pricing is comparable, but Rise & Shine offers more transparency about their approach.

Both companies offer free estimates. Both provide financing options. The actual repair costs are often similar for basic services like spring replacement or cable repair.

The key difference is in how technicians are paid.

Rise & Shine technicians are paid hourly. They have no incentive to upsell you. They diagnose your problem, explain your options, and let you decide. No pressure. No tricks.

“Jamison explained very clearly everything about my garage door opener problem and my options to fix things. He didn’t pressure me or try to upsell me for any of the options.” – Google Review

Precision does not publicly disclose their technician pay structure. This is common for franchise operations. Their reviews suggest professional service, but the pay model is not transparent.

Both companies offer discounts. Rise & Shine provides 5% off for seniors, military, and AAA members. Precision offers discounts for seniors, military, AAA, and first responders.

The verdict: Rise & Shine’s hourly pay model creates a more pressure-free experience. When technicians have no commission incentive, they focus on solving your problem, not maximizing the sale.

Which Offers Better Warranties?

Both companies provide solid warranty coverage.

Rise & Shine offers warranty options to fit any budget. They use the highest-quality parts in the industry. Their powder-coated options last longer in Minnesota weather. They stand behind their work completely.

Precision backs their work with the Neighborly Done Right Promise. This is a systemwide guarantee from their parent company. It promises professional, workmanlike service consistent with industry standards.

The real difference is not the warranty terms. It is what happens when you need warranty service.

With Rise & Shine, you call the same local team that did your original work. They know you. They know your door. They take care of you quickly.

With Precision, you call their central system. Your original technician might still be available. But you are working through a larger franchise operation.

The verdict: Warranty terms are similar. Rise & Shine’s local-only approach may make warranty service simpler and more personal.

Which Has Faster Response Times?

Both offer same-day service, but they approach it differently.

Rise & Shine offers same-day service seven days a week. They are available 6 am to 10 pm daily. They serve Minneapolis, St. Paul, and the metro area exclusively. This focused service area means faster response times.

Customers report that Rise & Shine often arrives within hours. Sometimes even faster.

“I called about 1:00. They scheduled an appointment between 2 and 4. Nick arrived at 1:40!” – Trustindex Review

Precision offers same-day service with evening and weekend availability. They have a 24/7 call center, which means someone always answers the phone. Their multiple locations help them cover more ground.

“They were able to get me an appointment within a couple of hours of me calling.” – Precision Website Review

The verdict: Both companies deliver fast service. Precision’s 24/7 call center is an advantage for late-night emergencies. Rise & Shine’s focused local coverage often means faster daytime response.

Local vs Franchise: Which Is Better?

Rise & Shine’s local ownership provides a more personal experience.

Rise & Shine is truly local. Alex and Josh built this company in the Twin Cities. They live here. Their families are here. When you hire Rise & Shine, you support a local business that reinvests in your community.

Every employee is trained in-house at their Go For Greatness Training Center. There are no corporate layers between you and the owners. If you have a problem, you can reach the people who make decisions.

Precision is locally owned within a franchise system. Tom, Kristi, Craig, and Erica run the Twin Cities operation. They are real local people with a stake in the community. But they operate within the Neighborly franchise structure.

The franchise model has benefits. Precision has access to national buying power, standardized training, and the Neighborly brand reputation. These resources help them serve customers well.

The trade-off is flexibility. Franchise operations follow corporate guidelines. Local-only companies can adapt faster to local needs.

The verdict: If supporting a truly independent local business matters to you, Rise & Shine is the clear choice. If you prefer the backing of a national brand, Precision is a solid option.

Local Considerations for Minneapolis and St. Paul

Garage doors in Minnesota take a beating. Winter cold. Summer heat. Spring storms. Your garage door system needs to handle all of it.

Rise & Shine has spent a decade learning what works in Twin Cities weather. They know which springs hold up best in extreme cold. They understand how humidity affects garage door openers. They stock parts that work reliably in Minnesota conditions.

They serve neighborhoods across Minneapolis and St. Paul, including Downtown Minneapolis, Uptown, Northeast Minneapolis, Highland Park, Cathedral Hill, Bloomington, Edina, Plymouth, and Maple Grove.

Precision also has strong local coverage. Their multiple locations in St. Paul, Apple Valley, Eden Prairie, Maple Grove, and Hudson help them reach customers throughout the metro area and into Western Wisconsin.

Both companies understand Minnesota. Both are equipped for local conditions. Rise & Shine’s decade of exclusive local focus gives them deeper roots in the community.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Rise & Shine better than Precision Garage Door in Minneapolis?

For most homeowners, yes. Rise & Shine has a perfect 5-star rating, hourly-paid technicians with no commission pressure, and true local ownership. Precision is also excellent with a 4.94-star rating and national brand support. Both are good choices, but Rise & Shine offers a more personal, pressure-free experience.

How much does Rise & Shine cost compared to Precision Garage Door?

Prices are similar for basic services. Both offer free estimates and financing. The difference is transparency. Rise & Shine technicians are paid hourly, so they have no incentive to upsell. This often results in more straightforward recommendations and pricing.

Does Rise & Shine serve all of Minneapolis and St. Paul?

Yes. Rise & Shine serves the entire Twin Cities metro area, including Minneapolis, St. Paul, and surrounding suburbs. They also cover Rochester. Call 612-886-9606 for the Twin Cities or 507-200-8833 for Rochester.

What is the difference between Rise & Shine and Precision Garage Door?

The biggest difference is ownership structure. Rise & Shine is a local, family-owned company that has served only the Twin Cities since 2015. Precision is part of Neighborly, a national franchise with 140+ locations. Rise & Shine pays technicians hourly with no commission. Precision does not disclose their pay structure.

Which company has better emergency service?

Both offer emergency service. Precision has a 24/7 call center, which is helpful for late-night emergencies. Rise & Shine is available 7 days a week from 6 am to 10 pm. For most situations, both respond quickly. Precision may have an edge for calls after 10 pm.

Do Rise & Shine technicians try to upsell?

No. Rise & Shine technicians are paid hourly, not on commission. They have no financial incentive to sell you things you do not need. They diagnose your problem, explain your options, and let you decide. This is a key reason customers trust them.

Is Precision Garage Door locally owned?

The Twin Cities Precision locations are locally operated by Tom and Kristi Hartmon and Craig and Erica Amundson. However, Precision is part of the Neighborly franchise system, which is a national company. They are not independently owned like Rise & Shine.

Final Verdict: Rise & Shine vs Precision Garage Door

Choose Rise & Shine Garage Doors if you want honest, local service with a perfect 5-star rating.

Both companies can fix your garage door. Both have skilled technicians. Both offer warranties and financing. Both have excellent reviews.

But Rise & Shine stands out for important reasons:

• Perfect 5-star rating across review platforms
• True local, family-owned business since 2015
• Technicians paid hourly with no commission pressure
• No subcontractors, ever
• In-house training at their Go For Greatness facility
• Over a decade of Twin Cities expertise

Precision might be right for you if you prefer a company backed by a national brand. Their 24/7 call center is helpful for late-night emergencies. Their multiple locations provide broad coverage. They offer good discounts for military, seniors, and first responders.

For most Minneapolis and St. Paul homeowners, Rise & Shine is the better choice. They have earned their reputation one satisfied customer at a time. They treat your home like their own. They solve problems instead of pushing sales.

Ready to experience the Rise & Shine difference?

Call 612-886-9606 for the Twin Cities or 507-200-8833 for Rochester. Visit callriseandshine.com to schedule online. Same-day service is available seven days a week.

Your garage door deserves honest service from people who care. That is what Rise & Shine delivers every single day.